Sometimes I go to the movies and skip the concession stand, content to feast solely on the action onscreen.

Such transcendence has never found me at a baseball game. Respectfully, Iโ€™ve come to view the sport as an outdoor dining experience: a picnic held around the edges of a field, a forum for eating phallic foods without eye contact.

And yet in years of attending Durham Bulls games, Iโ€™ve never ventured beyond ultraclassic concessions like hot dogs and peanuts. Part of that is just allegiance to the old guard, but fearโ€™s at play, tooโ€”a bad order could sour the whole outing.

This quandary eventually develops into an INDY assignment: If not a hot dog, which concessions should a Bulls fan pursue? 

The plan. Photo by Matt Ramey.
The plan. Photo by Matt Ramey.

I receive a budget of $100 and decide to prioritize โ€œdecision pointโ€ items, the ones you hesitate over at the counter wondering if youโ€™re about to drop $15 on something mid. The day of the game, I print out the Bullsโ€™ concessions map and plot out a tasting that includes a fried chicken sandwich, a vegan dog, and the nachos from the outpost of a local Mexican restaurant, among other fare.

In rating items, I plan to consider taste, price, and what Iโ€™m calling โ€œballparkliness,โ€ a foodโ€™s quality of being apt for the setting. Each item will receive a final score on a scale from strikeout to home run. For the occasion, I bring along my editor, Sarah, and a freelance photographer, Matt. The game we attend happens to feature a spectacle called โ€œ9 Weddings in 9 Inningsโ€ in which couples exchange vows on the field between innings. It is unclear to our group to what degree these proceedings qualify as real unions; several appear to be vow renewals, and the whole affair is hosted by a local radio station.

Regardless, the commitment on display makes for an ironic backdrop: Typically a hot dog monogamist, tonight Iโ€™ve come to play the field.

The author deliberates over an order at the Durham Bulls stadium. Photo by Matt Ramey.
The author deliberates over an order at the Durham Bulls stadium. Photo by Matt Ramey.

FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH

Vendor: Home Plate Chicken

Price: $11.50

The first concession I try is the fried chicken sandwich, a thing of strange dimensions.

While the bun is normal-sized, the cutlet is wide and cartoonishly thin, jutting past the edges of the bread like a snapback brim. I imagine its mythology: Once a plump fillet, it was lobbed to a batter who thwacked it so hard that it flattened to a disc and Frisbee-whizzed into the soft catch of a bun.

The only other ingredient in the sandwich is pickles. 

โ€œTemu Chick-fil-A,โ€ Matt declares. 

I take a bite with low expectations. Itโ€™s actually fineโ€”as moist as a skinty piece of chicken can be, with a lovely golden crunch.

My main gripe is with the bun. My thumbs leave dents that hold their shape, making me feel like Iโ€™m eating a stress ball. Iโ€™m sure this happens when I eat hot dogs, too, but since my hand cups those from the side, Iโ€™m usually spared the image of preservatives.ย 

Meanwhile, Sarah is having her own hand-related crisis. Wool E. Bull, the Bullsโ€™ mascot, has just come by decked out in a tuxedo for the nightโ€™s weddings, and his gloved hands, dwarfed by the bulk of his costume, are bothering her.

โ€œTheyโ€™re not proportionate,โ€ she says, cringing.

Glazed nuts at "9 Weddings in 9 Innings" night at the Durham Bulls. Photo by Matt Ramey.
Glazed nuts at “9 Weddings in 9 Innings” night at the Durham Bulls. Photo by Matt Ramey.

GLAZED PECANS

Vendor: dinkersยฎ glazed nuts

Price: $8

One inning in, the Bulls are down a pair and the first wedding is underway. The officiant leans into his mic. 

โ€œA marriage is a lot like a night out with White Claws,โ€ he begins, and I promptly tune out, turning my attention instead to a bag of glazed pecans I bought from a local vendor called dinkersยฎ.

The nuts are still toasty from the hotel pan they were lounging in back at the dinkersยฎ kiosk. Between that and their flavorsโ€”Canadian whiskey, cinnamon, and sugar cooked to the moment before it started to smokeโ€”they confer a rich amber warmth that feels out of place on a summer night.

What the nuts lack in ballparkliness, though, they make up for in a sticky nostalgic quality Iโ€™ll term โ€œcrackerjackitude.โ€ I inhale them until my molars are completely packed with caramel, then zone back into the ceremony.

โ€œBy the power vested in me by Mix 101.5,โ€ the officiant is saying, โ€œkiss your girl!โ€ 

He asks everyone to raise a drink. I hold up a nut.

A soft pretzel. Photo by Matt Ramey.

SOFT PRETZEL

Vendor: Home Plate Hot Dog

Price: $4.95

Iโ€™m forever on the verge of getting a soft pretzel only to talk myself out of it. Tonight, I have a real excuse to follow through.

My enthusiasm dims the moment itโ€™s passed over the counter. The pretzel has a stiff, inedible sheen, like someone dipped it in bat lacquer.

One bite wicks the moisture from my mouth; itโ€™s crusted in rock salt and stale to the core.

I hand it off to Matt, typing โ€œsand from the shore of the Dead Seaโ€ into my Notes app.

โ€œThis tastes like sand,โ€ Matt says, looking up from his own bite.

In better news, the Bulls just tied up the game.

Barbecue Platter. Photo by Matt Ramey.

BARBECUE PLATTER

Vendor: Home Plate BBQ

Price: $11.25

A number of local vendors have outposts throughout the concourseโ€”Pie Pushers, Two Roosters, Mezcalitoโ€”but homegrown food is also tucked into one of the more generic, Bulls-operated stands, Home Plate BBQ, which sources pulled pork from a wholesaler out of Greensboro.

The platter I get at Home Plate BBQโ€”pork, mac and cheese, coleslaw, and cornbreadโ€”delivers. The coleslaw, a soupy mound, forgoes crunch, but itโ€™s wonderfully seasoned, and all the liquid ends up going to useโ€”it soaks right into the cornbread, which is otherwise a touch dry. The pork is tangy-sharp on my palate but soft on my tongue, downy like cake crumbs.

The Impossible Veggie Dog. Photo by Matt Ramey.
The Impossible Veggie Dog. Photo by Matt Ramey.

IMPOSSIBLE VEGGIE DOG

Vendor: Home Plate Hot Dog

Price: $4.95

A few days before this outing, my pescatarian coworker told me that every time she eats a veggie dog at a Bulls game, she worries that they accidentally gave her a real oneโ€”as in, theyโ€™re just that on point.

It must have been a long time since sweet Chloe ate a real hot dog. Or maybe Iโ€™m catching the Home Plate Hot Dog stand, which also sold me the sand pretzel, on a bad night. Each bite tastes like a mouthful of bread wrapped around tacky, slightly denser bread.

Veggie Ultimate Nachos at the Durham Bulls. Photo by Matt Ramey.
Veggie Ultimate Nachos at the Durham Bulls. Photo by Matt Ramey.

VEGGIE ULTIMATE NACHOS

Vendor: Mezcalito Taco Stand

Price: $15.99

Ever since the Durham restaurant Mezcalito opened a satellite at the Bulls stadium a few years ago, Iโ€™ve been telling myself that their nachos must be overpricedโ€”a weird crotchetiness that likely stems from the fact that these nachos skyrocketed to popularity soon after debuting several years ago, a rookie everyone instantly became obsessed with.

My assignment tonight finally compels me to order some. The experience is humbling. The nachos arenโ€™t cheapโ€”$15.99 for the veggie versionโ€”but I get a mountain of food for the money, and each element dazzles me. Toppings that usually come skimped, like guac and chipotle mayo, are laid on thick. Queso graces every chip. I figured โ€œveggieโ€ would just mean no meat, but the chips come strewn with roasted zucchini, bell pepper, mushroom, and onion.

Compared to the dank fluorescence of other booths, the Mezcalito stand is also an oasisโ€”open air, draped in hanging plants. I feel like Iโ€™ve gone to hang out with the it-girl at school to find that she lives in a mansion and is also really nice.

As Iโ€™m feeling preemptively guilty about maybe shifting my default order away from the hot dog in the future, I hear a husband being shaded during a vow renewal. He โ€œnormally doesnโ€™t do big romantic gestures,โ€ says an officiant, reading a script that sounds like it was written by the guyโ€™s wife. But, the officiant continues, the husband has finally found it in himself to pull a gesture togetherโ€”re-upping his marriage at a Wednesday night Bulls game. 

I get it. Sometimes it takes a gimmick to break out of a rut.

  • Funnel cake. Photos by Matt Ramey.
  • Funnel cake. Photos by Matt Ramey.

FUNNEL CAKE

Vendor: Funnel Cake Kiosk

Price: $8.99

Itโ€™s the bottom of the eighth inning and the score has somehow swelled to 10-2 without me noticing. The Bulls are fried. Iโ€™ve got one more food to try.

Matt joins me for the walk to the funnel cake kiosk, immediately falling into banter with the crew behind the counter. Itโ€™s the end of the night, so they end up giving us a second cake for free. 

After a few pulls of dough, I decide this is the platonic ideal of a funnel cake: lace edges, squishy middle, buttery base note, beaucoup powdered sugar (one of the guys at the kiosk kept cranking until we told him โ€œwhenโ€).

With nothing left to taste, Matt, Sarah, and I lay the detritus of our meal on the ground to take a photo, explaining to the intrigued row of college students behind us that weโ€™re professional journalists. A minute later, one of them pipes up: Sheโ€™s a rising junior in journalism school, she says, and sheโ€™s curious if print newspapers are doing OK. We laugh uneasily, and I point to the caloric remnants below us, spread out like roadkill.

โ€œWhat does it look like?โ€ I quip.

We end up giving the students our extra funnel cake, a consolation for the younger generation. A few minutes later I turn around and ask them how it is. Mouths too full to answer, they give me big thumbs-ups and nod, faces dusted white with powdered sugar.

To comment on this story, email [email protected].

Lena Geller is a reporter for INDY, covering food, housing, and politics. She joined the staff in 2018 and previously ran a custom cake business.