Vines snake up the brick and past the boarded-up windows. Old theater seats and rotting wood sit in what used to be the auditorium, ruined by decades of rain that’s come through the gaping hole in the roof. Graffiti covers the peeling walls in the cafeteria, and exposed metal hangs from the ceiling where the tiles have fallen away.

Nestled between I-40 and NC-54 and just a few miles from the growing Research Triangle Park, the historic Lowe’s Grove School building is sitting on a prime piece of land. But after nearly a century of operation, Durham Public Schools shuttered the school’s doors in 1989 and left it to rot. Only now, after decades of decay earned DPS a citation from the City of Durham, is the district planning for the site’s future.

The likely course of action seems to be demolishing the building and selling the land for retail or housing, based on recommendations the school board heard from a consultant on October 8. A previous plan to build affordable housing for teachers on the property, introduced in 2017, stalled for years pending approval from the General Assembly. In the meantime, DPS continues to incur costs for property upkeep and threats of city fines, prompting the school board to move forward with a new plan for the site.

“There’s no need for us to continue to deal with that building being there in the condition that it is in, and there is liability possible that we can run into,” board member Wendell Tabb said at the October meeting. “So, I am for demolishing that building tomorrow.”

The UNC-Chapel Hill School of Government’s Development Finance Initiative (DFI), the consultant that DPS hired to conduct a feasibility study outlining possible development options for the site, will return to the board later this fall with cost estimates. DFI is still in early phases of developing recommendations but has found demand for some retail, single-family homes, and affordable housing, all of which would require DPS to tear down the building and sell the land either to the county or a developer. 

The board could choose to restore and reuse the building, but it would be expensive and there isn’t much that could be preserved. The decaying building needs to be gutted and requires new foundation and floors, DFI found. It is no longer eligible for historic tax credits, which are state and federal subsidies that help fund rehabilitation of historic buildings. 

The city cited the district several times over the past few years for failing to take care of the building or demolish it. But the city agreed to pause any related fines as long as the district had its consultant involved, and that extension lasts through January 8—putting DPS in a “time crunch,” Chief Operating Officer Kenneth Barnes warned the school board at the October meeting.

Credit: Photo by Tori Newby

The city first cited the property in October 2023 for wall, roof, and window damage, after receiving a call about teenagers playing in the building. The district did not take corrective action and failed multiple re-inspections. The city ordered DPS in February 2024 to repair or demolish the building by May of that year, finding that the cost of repairs would exceed half of its value. DPS failed to comply again.

DPS sought demolition bids the following September, and the city formally condemned the building as unsafe a few months later. Director of School Planning Devan Mitchell said she’s not aware of any fines the district has paid the city, considering they’ve received multiple extensions to complete the feasibility study.

DPS is also incurring minimal costs to keep up the property, including resecuring the building after break-ins. The fence currently has gaping holes, and the grass and vegetation is completely overgrown. It’s easy for anyone to get inside, proof being trash strewn about the property. Barnes said at the meeting that with winter approaching, people might take shelter in the building—a liability for the district considering the hazardous conditions.

But the price to demolish the building has doubled since the last time DPS asked for a quote in 2024. School board member Millicent Rogers told the INDY the board was holding out hope that the state legislature would authorize affordable housing for teachers in Durham, and the district could preserve some of the school building for that “as an homage to what has been.” The district decided to undertake a feasibility study last year to develop a long-term approach to the site, Mitchell said.  

“I wish we had taken action previously on the building,” Rogers said. “Demolishing that building doesn’t mean that we are no longer invested in having affordable teacher housing or moving that plan forward. But that site is in such disrepair, and I don’t know that the board was aware that the site was in such disrepair that it was no longer a feasible location.” 

Before it could put the property on the market, the district would have to deem it unnecessary for school purposes and give Durham County the option to buy it.

Because of the site’s proximity to Research Triangle Park and other amenities, the DFI consultants found it’s likely competitive for federal affordable housing tax credits. They also found there’s demand for single-family homes and retail. (DFI’s analysis covers the school and 13 surrounding acres.) 

Similar feasibility studies were conducted in the early 2000s, ahead of the South Regional Library’s opening in 2010 on part of the old school property. Now, the library’s windows directly face the old school building, which is the last of six still standing. 

‘Lowe’s Grove School Was Here’

Lowe’s Grove School first opened in 1896 as a Sunday school, in what was deemed the “dark corner” of Durham County because it lacked a school or a church. The Sunday school gave way to a one-room schoolhouse, and the county added more buildings over the next few decades. 

The school was called Lowe’s Grove Farm Life School, as it was funded by a federal grant that taught the boys agricultural skills and the girls “domestic science,” and the school had a farm on its property. An all-brick building remaining today opened in 1925. An issue of the school newspaper, called the Lowe’s Grove Reflector, reported at the time that “the new building will in every way be adequate for the long-felt need of our growing community.” 

The school, restricted for white students until county schools integrated in 1970, developed a loyal alumni base. But over time, the original campus was saddled with maintenance needs, and a 1985 report recommended closing the “dilapidated” buildings. 

Credit: Photo by Tori Newby

The DPS superintendent at the time said the site may become too valuable to continue operating a school, the Durham Morning Herald reported, considering it was in a “prime area for commercial development.”  

A group of parents and community members presented a petition to the school board with nearly 600 signatures, begging the district not to sell the building. About 35 area residents created the Historical Committee to Save Lowe’s Grove School. 

“I can see 10 years from now the highway department will put up a plaque that will say, ‘Lowe’s Grove School was here,’” a resident named Miss Godwin told a News & Observer reporter in December 1988, just months before the school closed. “That’s not enough. That’s not fair.”

Students were transferred to Pearsontown and Southwest elementary schools in the fall of 1989, and the 1925 building was declared eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. There was some discussion of selling the property to a historical developer or renovating it for retail, the N&O reported. 

But likely to Miss Godwin’s dismay, the DFI consultants found that the building is no longer eligible for the national historic register due to neglect and decay. 

Caitlin Avinger, executive director of advocacy group Preservation Durham, said she pushed for the district to do “whatever possible to save the building.” But after DFI’s feasibility study made clear that the building has lost much of its historic integrity and wouldn’t be eligible for historic tax credits, Avinger said the building is probably at the end of its useful life.

“The bigger question is why the building sat there for 35-plus years in its current state, without more of a plan to try to find a secondary use,” Avinger said. 

She said DPS should have plans for its buildings before they are vacated and consistent maintenance on empty properties. DPS is preparing for the Durham School of the Arts campus to be vacant once the new building is complete in 2028, and the old Northern High School building is sitting empty and ready for a new use. DFI has also been contracted for feasibility studies on those two sites.

The district is also considering closing some aging elementary schools, including Club Boulevard and George Watts Montessori—properties that the district could sell and generate revenue from “if it’s done right,” Avinger said. 

“So many of these buildings are part of the fabric of what make Durham visibly Durham,” Avinger said. “The goal is to balance preserving and protecting the buildings that show our character at the same time as updating as we need to.”

The DFI consultants have engaged some community stakeholders—including the neighboring library, a preschool, a church, and Research Triangle Park—and will ramp up engagement as they narrow down more realistic options for the old Lowe’s Grove School site.

Credit: Photo by Tori Newby

Rogers said confronting the future for Lowe’s Grove is an opportunity for the board to create a policy on addressing DPS properties when they’re no longer used for students; she anticipates the board voting on such a policy in the next year. 

“I wish our predecessors had set the standards to do so,” Rogers said. “… Our board now has the opportunity to set the precedent, and create policies and systems that will far outlive our term on the board, to help future boards be able to determine when is the right time to off-load property.”

Comment on this story at [email protected].

Tori Newby is a staff writer at the INDY and a recent graduate of UNC-Chapel Hill. She covers education and local government in Durham.