Ten years ago, Mettlesome Theater wasn’t a theater at all. It was a group of friends shuffling folding chairs from a garage into a driveway.

“Our very first show was in our garage,” co-founder Jack Reitz recalled. “We got some of our friends, put some chairs in the driveway, and put up a show. It was really fun.”

Reitz and his wife, Ashley Melzer, first met doing comedy. They knew each other for several years, including a period when Reitz lived and performed in New York City, before they began dating and he returned to the Triangle full-time.

Reitz studied and performed improv since 2004, training at DSI Comedy Theater in Chapel Hill and later at Upright Citizens Brigade and Magnet Theater in New York. Melzer, a filmmaker, writer, and improviser with a background in folklore and documentary storytelling, shared his interest in creating original comedy rooted in performers’ experiences.

That modest experiment grew into one of Durham’s busiest comedy institutions. Today, Mettlesome operates from Golden Belt, producing roughly 30 performances monthly with more than 100 regular performers and a payroll exceeding 25 people. Improvisational comedy remains the heart of its programming, from ensemble performances built around audience suggestions to original sketch productions and classes that train the next generation of comedians.

April Dudash, Ashley Melzer, Jack Reitz, Jonathan Yeomans, Lauren Foster-Lee, and Hillary Yonce of Mettlesome Theater in 2022. Photo by Brett Villena.
April Dudash, Ashley Melzer, Jack Reitz, Jonathan Yeomans, Lauren Foster-Lee, and Hillary Yonce of Mettlesome Theater in 2022. Photo by Brett Villena.

The theater also hosts plays, literary readings, music, and experimental productions. In August, its ambitious 10th- anniversary celebration featured 81 acts across two weekends, including Mettlesome alumni who returned from across the country to perform.

Yet in talking with Reitz, co-founder Ashley Melzer, and operations director April Dudash, these numbers seem secondary to something harder to quantify. By building a community around the conviction that diverse and adventurous art can thrive in Durham, they didn’t have to wait for validation.

“We’ve learned over the decade making art in Durham that art functions best when we are working in community with other artists,” Melzer said.

Before finding a permanent home, the Mettlesome collective performed wherever space was available, including Fullsteam, the Pinhook, Manbites Dog Theater, which closed in 2017, and a tiny theater behind Motorco that eventually disappeared beneath new development. Reitz and Melzer joke that much of theater is simply moving chairs. During the pandemic, when performances paused, company members continued gathering online for improv and weekly trivia nights. Many still perform and teach at Mettlesome.

“I think we always knew we had a community,” Melzer said. “It’s incredible how much that community has grown.”

That growth has accelerated. Mettlesome doubled its class offerings over the past year, attracting hundreds of students. Dudash regularly hears from newcomers who enroll simply to meet people, only to discover friendships, creative collaborators, and a sense of belonging.

 Linda Salas and Saoirse Finn perform in Show & Tell. Photo courtesy of Mettlesome Theater.
 Linda Salas and Saoirse Finn perform in Show & Tell. Photo courtesy of Mettlesome Theater.

But Mettlesome isn’t merely a social club with a stage. Its founders approach comedy as a serious artistic discipline, comparing improvisation to jazz that requires practice, studied collaboration, and technical skill.

“Our school is teaching people to be better comedians,” Reitz explained. “Confidence and friendships follow, but they are byproducts of developing the craft.”

That commitment has helped Mettlesome evolve from an indie upstart into an institution with a growing national reputation. Performers like Craig Cackowski (Community) and Judah Friedlander (30 Rock) have approached the theater about appearing there, while Saturday Night Live senior writer Bryan Tucker has mentored performers and collaborated on productions.

The connection became particularly meaningful when Brandon “Bam” Alston, a Raleigh native and Mettlesome performer, instructor, and board member, joined Saturday Night Live’s writing staff in 2026. Alston previously helped create Bullish, a Mettlesome sketch production directed by Tucker. 

“They care about inclusivity, and they care about great programming, and they cared about me. And then I think from there, I was really all in.”

brandon alston, mettlesome alumnus
and saturday night love writer

For Alston, who returned to the Triangle in 2021, Mettlesome offered more than a stepping stone to a larger comedy market. “Mettlesome is just such a great place to grow with a group of people that take comedy seriously,” he said. “I think it’s a wonderful thing to be able to find such high-quality programming in your backyard.”

He remembers joining Well Seasoned, an all-Black improv house team led by the late Josh Rowsey, as a turning point. The group gave him a community within a community. 

“They care about inclusivity, and they care about great programming, and they cared about me,” Alston said. “And then I think from there, I was really all in.”

Alston became a writer, performer, improviser, teacher, and board member. 

“It’s not just a theater that I’m popping in to do a show at and then going home and waiting for the next one,” he said. “It’s really a place where I made my home.”

For Mettlesome, that recognition matters because it has been earned without abandoning Durham. The theater’s history parallels the city’s transformation, including the disappearance of affordable performance spaces as development reshaped downtown. The founders understand the contradiction: Artists help make neighborhoods desirable, then struggle to remain as those neighborhoods become more expensive.

“People love Durham because Durham is weird and because Durham has art and culture and scrappiness and grit,” Reitz said.

“People love Durham because Durham is weird and because Durham has art and culture and scrappiness and grit.”

jack reitz, mettlesome co-founder

That commitment to place also informs Mettlesome’s distinctly Southern identity.

“We kind of have a chip on our shoulder about being Southern artists,” Melzer said. “Mettlesome exists because we want to be here. We want to tell our story. We want to do it in our voice.”

For Melzer, who grew up near the Florida-Georgia-Alabama border, Southern comedy should not rely on exaggerated accents or familiar stereotypes. It’s about allowing performers to draw on their actual experiences.

“Who you are and your perspective as a Southerner matters,” she said.

Looking ahead, the founders hope to expand sustainably without losing the experimentation that defined their first decade. Success, they suggest, isn’t simply a bigger theater or greater national recognition.

“In 10 years,” Reitz said, “I want Durham to be a place that people are moving to make art and not a place that people feel like they need to move away from in order to make art.”

To comment on this story, email [email protected].