Thursday night, the Durham Public Schools Board of Education rejected a contract proposal that would have initiated a “rightsizing and consolidation study” as part of the district’s efforts to address declining enrollment and aging facilities.
The contractor, MGT Impact Solutions, sought a bid to collect enrollment and demographic data, assess building capacity and facility needs, and offer recommendations to potentially close and consolidate schools. Now that the contract is rejected, a DPS facilities committee—made up of select administrators and board members—will be tasked with coming up with a plan to collect data the study would have included.
But further delay could hurt DPS’ ability to put its priorities into a bond referendum to fund facilities projects on the ballot in 2028, Director of School Planning Devan Mitchell warned. More than a third of DPS facilities are in poor or critical condition, Mitchell said, contributing to nearly $1 billion in maintenance needs across the district.
Board members Wendell Tabb and Millicent Rogers expressed concerns about delaying a consolidation study, after the board already directed administration to seek bids for the study in June and amend MGT’s draft contract earlier this month.
“If we delay anything, keep in mind that our children are first and they’re still sitting in these schools as we make these difficult decisions,” said Tabb, who chairs the facilities committee. “And it’s not necessarily fair to them that we continue to prolong, prolong, and prolong things—and they are still sitting in those seats.”
The school board was slated to vote on the contract November 5, but some board members worried about the company’s ties to private and charter schools, in addition to the level of community engagement that would be included in the study and whether DPS was ready to move toward closing schools. Board members also expressed concern over the cost of the contract, which is nearly half a million dollars.
The board directed administration to come back Thursday with a 12-month approach to the study that would have allowed the board to approve steps of the study in phases. Administration also amended the contract to include a conflict-of-interest disclosure, per the board’s direction, to address concerns regarding MGT’s company ties.
But, on Thursday, the board was still dissatisfied with the updated proposal, citing concerns from the community. Board members received about 40 emails and 1,300 people signed a petition put forth by the Durham Association of Educators and other local organizations opposing the consolidation study.
The purpose of the study would be to develop recommendations for balancing enrollment across the district, which could include consolidating students in aging schools—where the cost to repair exceeds the cost to replace—into newer and larger buildings.
DAE President Mika Hunter Twietmeyer spoke Thursday night opposing the MGT contract and said that school closures will drive away families. She said DAE is acutely aware of the district’s facility needs—with some classrooms at 89 degrees and others at 59—which is why the union is prioritizing building upgrades in its meet and confer sessions this year.
“We know that we can create a bond proposal with the resources we already have, without going down the path of rightsizing and consolidation straight from the school privatization playbook,” Hunter Twietmeyer said.
Community pushback also came from parents and students who don’t want their schools to close.
DPS student Luna Gomez told board members at the meeting that consolidating schools could make it more difficult to boost enrollment.
“We need a school where we feel connected to the community, feel seen and included, not just giant hubs where thousands of students disappear,” Gomez said. “If it is hard to be visible now, it will be even harder then. We know school buildings need maintenance and I am sure adults are very capable of coming up with great ideas to be able to find the funds to fix that.”
Superintendent Anthony Lewis emphasized that a consolidation study does not mean the district is closing schools, and that despite concerns with MGT’s background, the consultant would be hired to make objective recommendations for the district to decide on.
“The question isn’t simply whether we can afford to spend this money,” Lewis said. “It’s whether we can afford to make decisions of this magnitude without the information necessary to get them right.”
Board members Natalie Bent Kitaif and Gabby Rivero spoke in favor of seeking in-house methods or cheaper contractors to study the demographic data needed ahead of a 2028 bond. Board member Nadeen Bir said facility plans should be guided by a forthcoming Duke University study on Growing Together, DPS’ 2024 redistricting plan.
DPS administrators were visibly frustrated with the back-and-forth about the study. Chief Operating Officer Kenneth Barnes said putting out bids for the study and selecting a contractor to bring to the board, and then revising the contract, took five months.
“I just want to be clear that we’re going to need certain things from you guys when we put together the next [request for proposals] because we did exactly, exactly what the board asked us to do last time,” Barnes said.
Bent Kitaif said she doesn’t think DPS is ready for a consolidation study. Rogers responded that there are lots of things the school district wasn’t ready for—such as desegregation—but that it’s the elected officials’ jobs to navigate the district’s challenges.
“The district, like many districts across the country, is headed towards a fiscal cliff,” Rogers said. “And it’s important that we understand that we’re the elected leaders that need to be able to say that we have made evidence-based decisions, to support the students in our community.”
Comment on this story at [email protected].

